Joseph resided in Flushing, NY at time of wedding. The couple still resided in Flushing where Ann Frances Manley, Ann Frances Manley Dunscomb's great aunt died 10/21/1876 (Dunscombe family Bible). The Ely ancestry has his mother's maiden name (raising questions about his middle name) as "Firth" and "Frith" but apparently "Frith" is correct.